Sunday, 4 January 2009

Is Pakatan Rakyat on the Road to Self-Destruction ?

Read here article in Malaysia Insider

Excerpts: Read here for more

Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim knew that once the excitement of pushing Barisan Nasional all the way on March 8 was replaced by greed, personal interest, petty politics, narrow political ideology and race issues, he would have a battle keeping the dream of a two party system alive.

He knew that the euphoria which accompanied the Opposition’s super showing in Election 2008 could not be maintained indefinitely.

At some point, the heady mix of social activists, educationists, career politicians, professionals that made up Pakatan Rakyat would clash, the result of inexperience in governing; unrealistic expectations and differences in ideology.

This mixed constituency was a major plus point for the coalition during the election. They allowed Pakatan Rakyat to reach out to a wider spectrum of voters than the Barisan Nasional and allowed Pakatan Rakyat candidates to speak more convincingly on an important raft of issues, from corruption to the rights of Indians.

Will a Dream Turn into a Nightmare?

PAS and the Islamic State/Huddud Law

But Anwar knew that it would only be a matter of time before the hardliners in Pas lifted the lid on their pet topic — hudud and the Islamic state. This conservative spine of the party reluctantly agreed to put their main platform on the backburner in the run up to the polls.

With elections over and Pas in a strong position, it was going to be more challenging persuading Pas leaders to keep their calling card buried. Once hudud was raised again, DAP’s veteran politicians would strike back. This scenario is being played out right now following comments made by Pas’ Husam Musa during a debate with Umno’s Khairy Jamaluddin.

[Note: The DAP Youth wing has criticised the Penang Pas Youth wing for demonstrating against the ’I-Dance’ contest in the Pakatan Rakyat Penang State. More than 200 members of Pas Youth held a demonstration at the Permatang Janggus Mosque grounds, carrying various banners criticising the Pakatan Rakyat State Penang Government . Read here for more]

Race Creeping onto the Surface in Pakatan Rakyat

Anwar also understood one fact of political life in Malaysia — race is never far from the surface. What more when it is wrapped up in unrealistic expectations. The Malays, Chinese and Indians in Pakatan Rakyat were willing to speak the language of accommodation and unity in the run up to the polls. They had to be on the same wavelength to be taken seriously as an alternative to Barisan Nasional.

PKR’s S. Manikavasagam said as much when he criticised the party’s leadership. He alleged that PKR was a Malay-centric party, lamenting that Indians had not been offered senior positions in government-linked companies, state agencies and local councils.

We feel cheated, we are disappointed. Nothing has been done," he said, accusing Selangor Menteri Besar Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim of not keeping promises made to the Indian community.

Some Malay politicians in Pakatan Rakyat
are uneasy over the demands being made by the Indians and the uncompromising stance by DAP’s veteran leaders on several issues.

[Note: The Pakatan Rakyat Kedah State Govt announced that its new policy to increase 50% bumiputra quota for housing schemes (from previous BN'-Govt's 30 % quota) . The Menteri Besar said that it was to compel developers to build affordable homes for all Kedahans. Read here for more]

Ironically, the strong showing on March 8 led some Pakatan Rakyat MPs to believe that the role of their communities — and not the common platform or the excesses of BN — was pivotal in their electoral success. As a result, they pushed for positions and contracts, and sought instant remedies, some of which had been promised to them before the elections.

Anwar's Dilemma

Anwar knew that many of his political comrades came together because of their intense hatred for BN and what it stands for.

Once that anger dissipated, it was always going to be a challenge keeping everyone focused on the big goal — staying as one and keeping the two-party dream alive.

No comments: