Thursday 20 August 2009

UPDATED: Teoh Beng Hock's Death: Fingers Pointing at MACC's Selangor Deputy Director, Hishamuddin Hashim


Read here in malaysiakini for more

".....If the content of this (mystery) letter is true, then we must be thankful that there are righteous officers in the MACC who are willing to point out the bad hats in their ranks, whose purpose is only to serve the objectives of their political masters and not the nation....

....I believe there are officers who are religious, compassionate with credible good integrity. Thank you to this person who has thrown leads to the entire investigation. Let's stand together to pray for the truth to be revealed! We do hope for more good Malaysians such as him to fight for justice for the people.

...My respect and prayers for the whistleblowers in MACC! It takes great courage and a strong sense of decency to do what they have done, for the whistleblowers have everything to lose, and their only possible gain is only to see justice done. May God and the good people of Malaysia protect them!

....There are still good people around except their numbers are small and always get suppressed. Whoever this true son of Malaysia is, all the rakyat is with you. Our highest salute is for you.

.....MACC still possesses some decent human beings.

....Have no fear, my brother, it is God's will that you are chosen to be the saviour for Malaysia.You are our hero. We are with you till justice prevails.

Teoh Beng Hock fell to his death from the 14th floor of MACC Office
while being held under MACC custody

Read ENGLISH TRANSLATION of MYSTERY LETTER (below) AFTER the original Bahasa Malaysia version.

Read HERE for the Mandarin/Chinese translation of the letter

A mystery letter (see below) in Bahasa Malaysia written by anonymous persons claiming to be “MACC officers” had urged the authorities to probe the Selangor's MACC Deputy Director, Hishamuddin Hashim for involvement in the death of Teoh Beng Hock and for corruption.

The mystery letter, purportly to be written by anonymous MACC officers, says,
" Kami semua mengesyaki TP (Timbalan Pengarah Hishamuddin Hashim) yang bertanggungjawab dengan kematian Teoh Beng Hock.....
... beliau juga memberikan arahan kepada pegawai bawahan untuk mencari sedaya mungkin tentang kesalahan yang di lakukan oleh pihak Kerajaan Negeri Selangor. Beliau yang gelojoj, maka kematian Teoh Beng Hock telah terjadi.

.. Mengikut pada pengetahuan kami pegawai-pegawai SPRM Malaysia, TP mempunyai teknik soalsiasat yang tersendiri iaitu beliau selalu menyoalsiasat seseorang dengan cara memegang di bahagian hadapan tali pinggang individu dan mengangkatnya beberapa kali serta menggoncangnya..."

The mystery letter as follows: (the highlights are inserted)

ENGLISH TRANSLATION of the above Mystery Letter (reposted from HERE )


Respectfully, we would like to refer to the subject above.

We would like to inform you that we, officers of the Malaysian Anti Corruption Commission (MACC), feel obliged to expose the misconduct and bribery of a senior officer of the MACC, Deputy Director (DD) MACC Selangor PKPj I Hishamuddin bin Hashim, in connection with the case of TEOH BENG HOCK and another case involving the bungalow of DATO' SERI DR MOHAMAD KHIR BIN TOYO in Section 7, Shah Alam, Selangor.

2. For YBhg Tan Sri/Dato/Tuan/Puan's information, DD was directly involved in the investigations on the fraud case of the Selangor State Government's funds for YB Ean's (ADUN Seri Kembangan) allocation. His involvement was not just on official orders, but he has also given instructions to his subordinates to find, with any means possible, any evidence of wrongdoing by the Selangor State Goverment. He acted in this fashion because he has made a conspiracy with Khir Toyo to topple the government of Selangor. These (gelojoh) actions directly resulted in the death of Teoh Beng Hock. There arise a few suspicious questions that we, officers of the MACC Malaysia, ask on how Teoh Beng Hock could have died. We suspect the DD's involvement in the death of Teoh Beng Hock based on the following:

i) DD had ordered all MACC officers involved in the operation that he not be directly involved in the case. In fact, he was the one who gave all the orders in this operation and other operations in MACC Selangor. In fact, he was afraid to be involved directly because this could expose his conspiracy with Khir Toyo.

ii) The chemical investigators have discovered fingerprints and male DNA on the front side of both sides of Teoh Beng Hock's belt. Based on our, the officers of MACC Malaysia, knowledge, the DD has an individual style of investigative techniques which include interrogating a suspect by holding the front of his belt, lifting him a few times while shaking him.

iii) The process of collecting DNA on MACC Selangor officers was performed in 2 sessions. In the first session of collecting DNA, the DD made every effort to evade giving his DNA sample. The DD was said to have given his DNA sample in the second session, but suspicions arise because the DD gave his DNA sample in the privacy of his own office while all other MACC offiers including the MACC Director have given their DNA samples in a meeting room in the presence of many other individuals. Why did the DD give his DNA sample in a secretive fashion? Was the DNA provided really his DNA? We, the officers of the MACC Malaysia, feel puzzled that there was no one else in the presence of the DD when he allegedly gave his DNA sample? We recommend that the DNA Test on the DD must be done again, witnessed by a group of people who can be trusted.

iv) We have been informed that the DD had ordered his subordinates to erase/clean the fingerprints on the window that Teoh was believed to have fallen from. This was proven when the police could not find any signs of fingerprints, new or old, on the window. The question is, why did the DD order that this be done?

v) We suspect, based on information we have obtained, that the DD did not touch his punch-card when he left the office on the 16th of July 2009, at 6:10 am. This is important because it can prove that the DD was the last person to see Teoh. The question is, why did he not touch his punch-card when he is a person who always touches his punch-card. For the record, he is very diligent with his punch-card.

3. For YBhg Tan Sir/Dato/Tuan/Puan's information, the DD in question is very influential in the enforcement of investigation operations around Selangor and the rest of Malaysia. In MACC Selangor, he is the most important person who decides whether a case should be prosecuted even if the power should rest in the hands of the Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP). His decision is prompted by his personal interests and those of his co-conspirators. So, it is no surprise that he led the MACC Selangor Investigative Unit for decades, at least since the Selangor state government was under the helm of the Barisan Nasional government (Khir Toyo) until now. He was promoted ahead of schedule, from Grade 41 to Grade 54, over the course of 16 years without transfer to other positions or locations other than that of the MACC Selangor. Based on the MACC, any officer who has been promoted or who has worked for more than 5 years in a state should be transferred to a different location to avoid the officer being involved in local bribery. One of the reasons he was never transferred is because he was tasked to "take care of" the position of Dato' Seri Dr Khir Toyo in Selangor. As a result, Khir Toyo also "took care of" his position in Selangor as a favour.

4. As a result of his position in MACC Selangor for these many years, he has been involved in various cases of bribery and misuse of power. Some of the incidents of bribery or misuse of power that we have investigated are as follows:

i) Closing the case of Khir Toyo connected to the approval of a road construction project, in Sekinchan running 20.5 km valued at RM 92.5 million to a contractor that was nearly blacklisted, Meram Holdings. According to the JKR's estimates, the road should have cost less than RM 50 million. The subcontractor that did the work on the project was Cabaran Wangsa, owned by Pua Kim An, the landlord of a house that had once been rented by Khir, while another company director, Ahmad Tarmizi Tajjeury is a Khir crony that was also given 100 acres of land at a profit to him of at least RM 20 million.

ii) Owning assets that exceed his emoluments such as:
a. Owning a few rental houses of which one is a two storey terrace house that was purchased at a favourable price from Pemaju Kumpulan Lebar Daun Development Sdn Bhd, as a result of the closing of the case against the Group Executive Chairman, Dato' Noor Azman @ Noor Hizam bin Mohd Nurdin. The case was investigated by the then BPR Selangor for a few years together with various other houses owned by him. To remove public and subordinate suspicions, he lived in the Government Quarters in Kg Atap, Kuala Lumpur.

b. Owning a Petronas petrol station on the left of the Federal Highway KM 8.6 - 8.7, Section 1, Federal Highway, Shah Alam, 40000 Selangor (near the Melati Roundabout, Shah Alam to Klang bound, registered under the name of his brother. The petrol station only just began operating this year (2009), part of which was built above a Chinese cemetary. He managed to get the site to build the petrol station because of his power, which was exercised in the era of Khir Toyo's government in Selangor.

c. Owning several plots of land around Shah Alam, in which one of them is believed to be beside the new SACC Mall registered under the name of a wife of a MACC Selangor driver named Abdullah b Azim, a full time homemaker in her late 30s.

iii) He has been caught in close proximity (khalwat) with a subordinate officer, Investigator rank, named Nor Azlina bt Mustafa besides the Shah Alam Lake early in 2009 by 2 police officers. He showed his identity card (MACC) and informed the police officers that he and the officer were in the middle of an operation and they were released. These "intimacies" between him and the Investigator were repeated and are common knowledge of many including his own wife. The only action taken by the Department was transferring the officer involved to the MACC Headquarters in Putrajaya. This was not effective because Azlina is still always with the DD in the Selangor office.

5. This letter was written to uphold justice and prevent the further abuse of power especially in the MACC and throughout Malaysia. We in the MACC are fed up to see his antics which have the blessings of the powers that be, like the saying "beraja di mata, bersultan di hati". We in the MACC are at lost in finding departments/institutions/NGOs that can champion this issue so that appropriate actions can be taken.

6. We, the officers of the MACC, are touched and thankful that YBhg Dato'/tuan/puan could expose this issue to the people and the authorities so that an organisation/NGO can take the appropriate action, or an independent investigation, can be taken and raised to the Cabinet. This is very important because it involves the integrity of a serving officer of a department that upholds the laws involving human integrity. The DD is now making every effort to press his subordinates to find any faults involving ruling PKR in the hopes that the PKR-led government will fall in Selangor and his secret will be safe. For your information, the DD is now very afraid whenever news about Dato' Seri Khir Toyo is released in the press and he would be very afraid if the case would expose his involvement.

7. We hope that any brave individuals or organizations can spread this information so that our actions can be brought to the attention of responsible and trusted authorities and that justice can be done. We are unable to do this ourselves because he has a "cable" with the powers that be.

8. Cooperation from YBhg Tan Sri/Dato'/tuan/puan is much appreciated and we hope that through your action, much more information can be brought to light involving individuals with no integrity. We hope that this will cleanse the MACC and its officers from further involvement in bribery and corruption.

Sekian, terima kasih


Kami yang menurut perintah,


Malaysiakini's Brief Summary of the Mystery Letter.

EXCERPTS: Read here for more

The mystery letter which emerged at the Teoh Beng Hock inquest yesterday is believed to contain claims connecting a top ranking MACC officer to the interrogation of the political aide, which could have led to his death.

Believed to be written by a Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission insider, the letter alleged how the top officer and an influential politician had worked together to start investigations into alleged corrupt practises by Selangor's Pakatan Rakyat leaders.

And it was on this understanding that Teoh was called up for questioning.

The unsigned letter, which carried the MACC official letterhead and written in Bahasa Malaysia, also stated the top officer's modus of interrogation - which involves pulling the suspects by the belt.

It further alleged that the top official was questioning Teoh on the day the DAP man was found dead. However the letter did not state on how Teoh died or if the officer was directly involved in his death.

Further claims made in the letter include:
  • The officer did not punch out from work when he left Plaza Masalam where the Selangor MACC is located on that day. However, the letter stated the time of him leaving the office. This is important as it could show that this officer was the last person to have seen Toeh on that day, alleged the letter.
  • The officer did not provide his DNA samples along with his other colleagues. He only gave a sample privately at a later day.
  • That he ordered his officers to wipe clean the window from where Teoh had apparently fallen from.
  • His alleged corrupt practices while investigating previous cases and that he is generally corrupt.
  • He had helped close an investigation on the politician.

The letter also stated that the top officer had been serving in the state for a long time, well beyond the usual five-year term for high ranking officials.

The letter also claimed that he was living beyond his means by having several houses, a petrol station in Shah Alam and several plots of land, courtesy of the politician's goodwill.

He was also allegedly caught for khalwat with his junior officer at the Shah Alam lake early this year.

Related Article

MACC Selangor Deputy Director Hishamuddin Hashim was the last person to have seen Teoh Beng Hock Alive

On 5th August, Malaysian Insider reported:

The last man believed to have seen Teoh Beng Hock alive was seen leaving the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) office here at 6.10am on the same day the DAP political aide’s body was later discovered, the coroner’s court was told today by lawyer Tan Hock Chuan.

The man, MACC officer Hishamuddin Hashim, was among a number of anti-graft officers identified by security guards from closed circuit television cameras (CCTV) photographs leaving and entering the building.

Security guard Abd Rahman Rahim, who was manning the lobby floor counter the same day Teoh’s body was found dead sprawled on a fifth floor balcony of the building, was the last witness. He had successfully identified two out of three men snapped as they were leaving the building from a series of CCTV photographs as MACC officers.

He recognised the third officer, who was later revealed to be the deputy director of the Selangor MACC (HISHAMUDDIN HASHIM) and even named the first officer, whom he knew casually, as “Ashraf”. Read here for more

Kes Teoh Beng Hock : Timb Pengarah SPRM Selangor Ada Dalam Rakaman CCTV

Gambar Timbalan Pengarah Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) Selangor, Hishamuddin Hashim antara yang diperoleh daripada rakaman kamera litar tertutup (CCTV) lobi Plaza Masalam, Seksyen 9, di sini pada awal pagi hari, Teoh Beng Hock ditemui mati 16 Julai lalu. Read here for more


Anonymous said...

the letter was written on 5th ogos ?
15 long days ago ? why appeared NOW ?

Anonymous said...

more will be implicated...hahaha...
if the letter was to be appear earlier, then we wouldn't know who is lying in the inquest.. now we all know who bullshitting us during the inquest!!

So what's the punishment for lying in an inquest?

Anonymous said...

What happens now? Easy answer. Scramble for quick-fix excuses and more lies to manipulate the cover-up game. When the facts all point to some irresistible inferences, you need to plant some red herring and adopt some quick diversive tactics. Even when you are caught with your pants down with a woman in a hotel room you can always explain to your wife you are only going to the washroom for a pee. Elementary.

Anonymous said...

The LORD has said , " vengeance is mine ! "

Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...

Why they tend to be in silent mode?Come and show up!His family are dying to know the truth.

Anonymous said...

A firm in DNA research as publish by the Star on 21/8/2009 stating that DNA can be easily falsified within a hours. Shoudn't it appear the timing within the research report?

Anonymous said...

People... read carefully... all these articles starts with the letter "IF". "IF" people think that this letter sheds the "truth", then keep being misled... Naive people can always be led by play on words and the big word is "IF". People DO NOT re-read articles when it starts with "IF". IF this did not happen, then, what? Remember "IF" is not the truth and in most cases it never is.